<p>Tia, an Australian cockatoo, sounds almost human when she says "hallo," "bye bye," "I love you," and dozens of other words and phrases. She even utters them in the correct context. So why doesn't this count as language? The only meaningful distinction between human speech and nonhuman animal vocalizations, says biologist Marc Hauser of Harvard University, is the power of recursion: Humans alone can take discrete elements such as words or numbers and combine them to create an infinite variety of expressions. </p><div class="vert-display-toggle collapsible relative flex flex-col items-center "><div class="vert-unit mt-4 mb-3 top-20"><div ad-type="mobile-desktop" class="ad-wrapper vert min-h-boombox flex items-start justify-center" data-ad-mapping="inline" data-ad-slot="Discover/inline-ad" id="div-inline-ad-0"></div></div><span aria-label="Advertisement" class="text-ad mt-1 text-[11px] uppercase">Advertisement</span></div><p> Hauser, working with linguist Noam Chomsky of MIT and psychologist W. Tecumseh Fitch of the University of St. Andrews in Scotland, has observed that nearly all of the ways humans produce and perceive sounds have close parallels within the animal kingdom. Birds learn their songs by listening to others of their species. Rats and pigeons can acquire the concept of numbers, although they cannot count very high. Many primates can distinguish between two different human languages on the basis of rhythm. Even the descended larynx deemed necessary for human speech is found in other mammals—in red and fallow deer, for example. Only the skill of recursion sets us apart, Hauser claims. </p><p> Hauser speculates that humans may have developed the power of recursion because of a growing need to engage in transactions involving complex numbers. "One pressure for such a system might be when we evolved the capacity for complicated social exchange. Suppose I give you 24 mongongo nuts and later you give back 22. If I can quantify that, I'm going to say, no, that's not fair, you owe me two. That recursive element seems to have created a revolution in terms of what we can communicate about," he says.</p><div data-embedid="dcfb67aa-fdf4-4a19-b4c7-75c497a8de9c" id="insticator-embed-temp"></div>

May 2003

Mars or Bust

Explore how Tia, an Australian cockatoo, challenges our understanding of language and communication nuances found in animals.

Planet Earth

And What Does a Human Say?

Article

News

Josie Glausiusz

Science

Tia, an Australian cockatoo, sounds almost human when she says "hallo," "bye bye," "I love you," and dozens of other words and phrases. She even utters them in the correct context. So why doesn't this count as language? The only meaningful distinction between human speech and nonhuman animal vocalizations, says biologist Marc Hauser of Harvard University, is the power of recursion: Humans alone can take discrete elements such as words or numbers and combine them to create an infinite variety of expressions. Hauser, working with linguist Noam Chomsky of MIT and psychologist W. Tecumseh Fitch of the University of St. Andrews in Scotland, has observed that nearly all of the ways humans produce and perceive sounds have close parallels within the animal kingdom. Birds learn their songs by listening to others of their species. Rats and pigeons can acquire the concept of numbers, although they cannot count very high. Many primates can distinguish between two different human languages on the basis of rhythm. Even the descended larynx deemed necessary for human speech is found in other mammals—in red and fallow deer, for example. Only the skill of recursion sets us apart, Hauser claims. Hauser speculates that humans may have developed the power of recursion because of a growing need to engage in transactions involving complex numbers. "One pressure for such a system might be when we evolved the capacity for complicated social exchange. Suppose I give you 24 mongongo nuts and later you give back 22. If I can quantify that, I'm going to say, no, that's not fair, you owe me two. That recursive element seems to have created a revolution in terms of what we can communicate about," he says.

Discover Magazine’s award-winning journalism inspires and informs, delivering thought-provoking content that sparks meaningful conversations. With a focus on groundbreaking developments in science, technology, and the world around us, Discover highlights the impact of these innovations on our daily lives.

人类会说什么？

新闻简报

Josie Glausiusz

发表于

火星，不成功便成仁

逃过灭绝的史前树木——银杏等至今仍繁茂生长

三种新发现的蟾蜍以奇异的进化方式产下活体幼崽

弓头鲸可活到200岁，其DNA可能蕴含长寿的秘密

切尔诺贝利的狗神秘变蓝，但辐射并非罪魁祸首

深海发现食肉死亡球海绵及其他新物种

这些吸血鬼鹿拥有三英寸长的獠牙而非鹿角来抵御对手

在寻找“耐力号”沉船时，意外发现了一个隐藏的鱼类社区

吸血蜘蛛痴迷于人类血液，通过扑向蚊子来饱餐一顿

最稀有的海洋动物及其他6种神秘潜伏在深海的难以捉摸的生物

冰岛首次发现蚊子，可能与气候变化有关

这些蝙蝠在紫外光下会发出绿光，但原因仍然是个谜

不再是“料理鼠王”——芝加哥鼠洞实则被一只松鼠压扁

蝠鲼潜入近4000英尺深的海洋——不是为了觅食，而是为了寻找方向

鲸鱼和海豚为何会搁浅，痴呆症是罪魁祸首吗？

狗如何看世界？它们确实能看到颜色，但更关注我们

保持好奇

加入我们的列表

订阅杂志